Choosin' Texas I Can Tell
By Josh Blackman · Nov 3, 2026, 10:31 PM CST
A few moments ago, the networks called the Texas Senate and Governor races for the Democratic candidates. Those outcomes will get a lot of attention. But of significant interest will be the downballot judicial races in Texas. This year, four of the nine seats on the Texas Supreme Court were on the ballot. Unless something unexpected happens, all four will lose: Chief Justice Jimmy Blacklock, Justi
Excerpt shown under fair-use limits. Full text remains with the original publisher.
People in this coverage
Explore their history and attributable record. Being mentioned does not imply endorsement.
Layer 1 · Claims & fact checks
AI analysisLayer 3 · Reporting analysis
AI analysisSpeculative ForecastingThe author presents a definitive outcome for multiple judicial races without any supporting data, framing the prediction as inevitable.
Appeal to AuthorityThe mention of Supreme Court clerkships is used to bolster the perceived qualifications of the judges, yet no source is provided to verify this claim.
Partisan FramingThe author frames the elections as purely partisan, dismissing any role of merit, which reflects a partisan interpretation rather than balanced reporting.
Emotive LanguageThe use of vivid, emotionally charged terms like "bloodbath" aims to dramatize the expected outcomes and influence reader perception.
Future Impact ProjectionThe author projects specific policy changes without citing any statements from the candidate or legal analysis, presenting conjecture as likely fact.
Context
AI analysisMissing context
The article does not provide actual election results for the judicial races, any polling data, historical voting patterns, or explanations of how Texas judicial elections work (e.g., partisan vs. nonpartisan, the role of primaries). It also omits any discussion of the legal implications of a shift in court composition, the specific powers of the Texas Governor and Attorney General, or the procedural details of judicial appointments and confirmations.
Important context
The piece was published on Reason Magazine on November 4, 2026, the same day the elections were being called. It is presented as an opinion column, not a news report, and therefore does not meet journalistic standards for sourcing or verification. The predictions about judicial races lack any cited polls, official results, or expert analysis, and the article does not reference any primary sources such as election returns, court filings, or statements from the candidates or officials mentioned.
Opinion vs. reporting
AI analysisThe text is primarily opinion and speculation. It intersperses a single factual statement (the networks calling the Senate and Governor races) with numerous unsubstantiated predictions and value‑laden language (e.g., "brilliant judges," "bloodbath," "strategic litigation cases will be severely underutilized"). No evidence or citations are provided to support the claims, indicating a lack of reporting standards.