Fact check
“Alito says that in McDonald v. City of Chicago, prominent scholars urged the court to jettison Due Process incorporation and revive the Privileges or Immunities Clause.”
Reasoning
The evidence supports the existence of a scholarly brief in McDonald v. City of Chicago with the described arguments, but there is no citation or quotation showing Justice Alito made the claim. Without a source linking Alito to the statement, the claim cannot be verified.
On confidence: The provided source confirms that scholars filed a brief urging the court to jettison Due Process incorporation and revive the Privileges or Immunities Clause, but it does not contain any statement by Justice Alito indicating he said this.
Important context
The excerpt is from a secondary report summarizing oral arguments and scholarly activity; it does not attribute the described viewpoint to Justice Alito.
Evidence
Supporting (1)
- Tier 3 — Secondary reportingJustice Alito on Originalism
importance. In McDonald [v. City of Chicago], prominent scholars filed a brief urging the court to jettison Due Process incorporation and revive Privileges or Immunities. During oral arguments, the attorney representing Otis McDonald…
Limitations
Only a single secondary source was provided, and it does not include any direct remarks from Justice Alito. Additional primary sources (e.g., transcripts, speeches) would be needed to confirm Alito's alleged statement.
- Last verified:
- Oct 6, 2026, 12:38 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
Justice Alito on OriginalismReason · Ilya Somin