Fact check
“The denial letter cited investigations by Marshfield Wisconsin Police, SUNY Police, Cortland Police, the FBI, and NY Child Protective Services.”
Reasoning
The source includes the exact wording of the denial letter stating investigations by Marshfield Wisconsin Police, SUNY Police, Cortland Police, the FBI, and NY Child Protective Services.
On confidence: High confidence due to direct quotation.
Important context
The excerpt is from a Reason.com article discussing the denial of a pistol permit and cites the letter as evidence.
Evidence
Supporting (4)
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDenial of Pistol Permit Based on Allegedly "Unsubstantiated" Past Allegations of Sexual Misconduct and Child Abuse
police, issued a formal denial letter, stating "over the course of several years you have been investigated by multiple different agencies, to include Marshfield Wisconsin Police, SUNY Police, Cortland Police, the FBI, and NY Child…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDenial of Pistol Permit Based on Allegedly "Unsubstantiated" Past Allegations of Sexual Misconduct and Child Abuse
allegations was ever substantiated and that no investigating authority ever found evidence of McWilliams's wrongdoing. I now summarize each of the allegations that McWilliams cites in his complaint. First, McWilliams provided housing to…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDenial of Pistol Permit Based on Allegedly "Unsubstantiated" Past Allegations of Sexual Misconduct and Child Abuse
the City of Middletown for a pistol and revolver permit. The police chief is responsible for issuing that permit and he "must determine if the applicant is a 'suitable' person." White, the MPD police officer, investigated McWilliams's…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDenial of Pistol Permit Based on Allegedly "Unsubstantiated" Past Allegations of Sexual Misconduct and Child Abuse
stating that the department "had not established any probable cause to arrest [McWilliams]." McWilliams further maintains that Marshfield police investigated those claims and "concluded they were baseless." Second, McWilliams fostered two…
Limitations
The verification relies solely on the quoted excerpt; the original letter itself was not independently examined. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.
- Last verified:
- Oct 5, 2026, 8:43 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
Denial of Pistol Permit Based on Allegedly "Unsubstantiated" Past Allegations of Sexual Misconduct and Child AbuseReason · Eugene Volokh