Fact check
“In Ziglar v. Abbasi (2017), Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote that the Court has largely narrowed civil liability claims against federal officers to violations of the Fourth, Fifth, and Eighth Amendments.”
Reasoning
The evidence includes a commentary excerpt attributing a statement to Justice Kennedy about "officers to violations of the Fourth, Fifth, and Eighth Amendments" but does not provide the full context or confirm that Kennedy made the broader claim that civil liability is largely narrowed to those amendments. Another excerpt discusses Bivens and qualified immunity without mentioning specific amendments. Without the actual opinion text, the claim cannot be verified.
On confidence: The provided excerpts do not contain a direct quotation or clear summary from Justice Kennedy stating that civil liability claims are limited to Fourth, Fifth, and Eighth Amendment violations.
Important context
Ziglar v. Abbasi (2017) is a Supreme Court case addressing qualified immunity and Bivens actions, but the exact language of Justice Kennedy's opinion regarding the scope of civil liability and specific amendments is not presented in the supplied sources.
Evidence
Supporting (3)
- Tier 4 — CommentaryCalifornia law lets residents sue federal agents over constitutional violations
officers to violations of the Fourth, Fifth, and Eighth Amendments, provided the conduct is "in a new context," as Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in Ziglar v. Abbasi (2017). Under that precedent, any case brought against a federal official…
- Tier 4 — CommentaryCalifornia law lets residents sue federal agents over constitutional violations
damages if the act occurs while they are performing their duty. In Harlow v. Fitzgerald (1982), the Court established that government officials are entitled to qualified immunity when their conduct does not "violate clearly established…
- Tier 4 — CommentaryCalifornia law lets residents sue federal agents over constitutional violations
the federal government itself," Pfander adds, "but they can establish norms that are equally applicable to all, and the Court has been pretty clear that there's no federal supremacy preemption in circumstances where the regulatory energy…
Limitations
The assessment relies solely on the provided commentary excerpts, which may paraphrase or interpret the opinion. No primary source or full opinion text is available to confirm the precise wording or legal holding.
- Last verified:
- Oct 1, 2026, 4:36 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
You Can Now Sue Federal Agents in California. Good Luck Getting Past Qualified Immunity.Reason · Tosin Akintola