Fact check
“Judge Ryan Nelson dissented in the Ninth Circuit decision, criticizing the majority's reliance on Bruen footnote 9.”
Reasoning
The provided evidence from Reason.com directly mentions Judge Ryan Nelson's dissent and his criticism of the majority's use of Bruen footnote 9 in the Ninth Circuit en banc decision. No contradictory information is presented.
On confidence: Multiple excerpts from a primary source explicitly state that Judge Ryan Nelson dissented in the Ninth Circuit's Yukutake decision and criticized the majority's reliance on Bruen footnote 9.
Important context
The claim pertains specifically to Judge Ryan Nelson's dissenting opinion in the Ninth Circuit's Yukutake v. Lopez case and his commentary on Bruen footnote 9.
Evidence
Supporting (3)
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceSecond Amendment Roundup: Bruen’s Footnote 9 Not a Carve-Out from Text and History
restrictions not based on text or historical tradition, some lower courts have latched onto, and purported to find an expansive meaning in, footnote 9. The latest example is the Ninth Circuit's September 22 en banc decision in Yukutake v.…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceSecond Amendment Roundup: Bruen’s Footnote 9 Not a Carve-Out from Text and History
Second Amendment Roundup: Bruen's Footnote 9 Not a Carve-Out from Text and History Judge R. Nelson’s dissent from 9th Circuit’s Yukutake decision thoroughly analyzes footnote 9. Stephen Halbrook | 9.29.2026 9:46 PM Having found the…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceSecond Amendment Roundup: Bruen’s Footnote 9 Not a Carve-Out from Text and History
Nelson, jointed by Judges Daniel Bress, Lawrence VanDyke, Bridget Bade, and Danielle Forrest. The following are some of the leading comments on footnote 9 in Judge Nelson's dissent. There are actually more references to footnote 9…
Limitations
The evidence is limited to a single source (Reason.com) and does not include the full text of the dissent or other independent reporting, but the excerpts are clear and specific. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.
- Last verified:
- Oct 1, 2026, 4:50 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
Second Amendment Roundup: Bruen's Footnote 9 Not a Carve-Out from Text and HistoryReason · Stephen Halbrook