Fact check
“Todd Butler’s student note favors Justice Breyer’s dissent in Hudson v. Michigan.”
Reasoning
The provided evidence quotes Butler's student note, indicating his preference for Justice Breyer's dissenting reasoning on the knock-and-announce rule and deterrence analysis, confirming the claim.
On confidence: Two independent excerpts from the same primary source directly state that Butler's student note favors Justice Breyer's dissent over Justice Scalia's majority in Hudson v. Michigan.
Important context
The evidence comes from a Reason.com article analyzing Butler's publications, which includes direct quotations from his student note.
Evidence
Supporting (2)
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceTodd Butler's Problematic Publications
Rev. 413 (2021) I haven't studied the articles carefully, but one through line seems to be a criticism of Justice Scalia. For example, in his student note, Butler favors Justice Breyer's dissent over Justice Scalia's majority opinion in…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceTodd Butler's Problematic Publications
"better trained police" provide adequate deterrence.. . . . Justice Breyer's dissenting opinion in Hudson v. Michigan aptly noted that "the Court destroy[ed] the strongest legal incentive to comply with the Constitution's…
Limitations
The evidence is limited to the excerpts presented; the full student note was not reviewed, but the quoted passages are sufficient to support the claim. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.
- Last verified:
- Oct 2, 2026, 3:36 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
Todd Butler's Problematic PublicationsReason · Josh Blackman