Fact check
“Alito recounts that Justice Scalia interrupted an attorney in McDonald arguing for the Privileges or Immunities Clause, stating it was contrary to a century of case law.”
Reasoning
The evidence from the Reason.com article cites Justice Alito recounting Justice Scalia's interruption of counsel during oral arguments in McDonald v. City of Chicago, including Scalia's remark that the Privileges or Immunities argument was "the darling of the professoriate" and contrary to a century of case law. This directly confirms the claim.
On confidence: The provided primary source directly quotes Justice Scalia's interruption and his statement about the Privileges or Immunities argument being contrary to a century of case law.
Important context
The statement reflects the context of oral arguments in McDonald, where scholars advocated for reviving the Privileges or Immunities Clause, and Scalia responded by urging reliance on established precedent.
Evidence
Supporting (1)
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceJustice Alito on Originalism
importance. In McDonald [v. City of Chicago], prominent scholars filed a brief urging the court to jettison Due Process incorporation and revive Privileges or Immunities. During oral arguments, the attorney representing Otis McDonald…
Limitations
The verification relies on a single secondary source summarizing Alito's recollection; no direct transcript of the oral argument is provided. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.
- Last verified:
- Oct 6, 2026, 12:38 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
Justice Alito on OriginalismReason · Ilya Somin