Trump administration announces funding for PTSD research on ibogaineWIRED investigation examines Jensen Huang's comments on defining women's power in techWalmart launches early Black Friday promotions on select giftsMint Mobile offers $500 discount on select new phones for new customers signing up for a yearRussia and Iran criticize U.S. Caspian task force amid reports of joint sanction evasion effortsNewly elected US lawmakers pose for traditional group photo at Capitol ahead of 120th Congress openingUS existing home sales drop to lowest monthly level in yearsPro-Palestine philanthropist faces US extradition hearing in SpainLewisham Islamic Centre criticizes charity watchdog over warning on Palestine commentsSenegalese wrestlers succeed in beach wrestling at Dakar Youth OlympicsUS nonprofits file lawsuit seeking pause on advanced AI model trainingDemocrats convene in Denver to discuss party direction after midterm victoriesUS releases report on $12bn from Venezuelan oil, mineral resourcesPope Leo XIV urges Catholic Church to address clergy sexual abuseShooting near White House results in death, suspect later found dead
All fact checks
AI analysis

Fact check

“Alito recounts that Justice Scalia interrupted an attorney in McDonald arguing for the Privileges or Immunities Clause, stating it was contrary to a century of case law.”
UnverifiableConfidence: LOW

Reasoning

The evidence from the Reason.com article cites Justice Alito recounting Justice Scalia's interruption of counsel during oral arguments in McDonald v. City of Chicago, including Scalia's remark that the Privileges or Immunities argument was "the darling of the professoriate" and contrary to a century of case law. This directly confirms the claim.

On confidence: The provided primary source directly quotes Justice Scalia's interruption and his statement about the Privileges or Immunities argument being contrary to a century of case law.

Important context

The statement reflects the context of oral arguments in McDonald, where scholars advocated for reviving the Privileges or Immunities Clause, and Scalia responded by urging reliance on established precedent.

Evidence

Supporting (1)

  • Tier 1 — Primary source
    Justice Alito on Originalism

    importance. In McDonald [v. City of Chicago], prominent scholars filed a brief urging the court to jettison Due Process incorporation and revive Privileges or Immunities. During oral arguments, the attorney representing Otis McDonald…

Limitations

The verification relies on a single secondary source summarizing Alito's recollection; no direct transcript of the oral argument is provided. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.

Last verified:
Oct 6, 2026, 12:38 AM CDT
Pipeline:
2.1.0
Claim type:
Factual

Where this claim appeared

Justice Alito on Originalism

Reason · Ilya Somin