St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy is a case involving Catholic preschools and Colorado's nondiscrimination requirements.
Unverifiable
Both the Law and Religion Forum article and the Reason.com piece describe St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy as a lawsuit concerning Catholic preschools and Colorado's nondiscrimination requirements, confirming the claim.
Examine fact check →Colorado operates a universal preschool program that provides public funding for children attending participating schools, including religious schools.
Unverifiable
The provided evidence explicitly describes Colorado's universal preschool program as publicly funded and open to religious preschools, noting that these schools must adhere to the same nondiscrimination rules as other participants. This directly corroborates the claim.
Examine fact check →Participating schools in Colorado's preschool program must agree not to discriminate on several grounds, including sexual orientation and gender identity.
Unverifiable
The claim is directly corroborated by two excerpts from the same source, which describe the nondiscrimination requirement for schools participating in the Colorado preschool program, specifically mentioning sexual orientation and gender identity as protected categories.
Examine fact check →Catholic preschools argue that the nondiscrimination requirements interfere with their religious mission, which includes teaching Catholic doctrine about marriage and requiring families to support that teaching.
Unverifiable
Both excerpts from the Reason.com article quote Catholic preschools' position on nondiscrimination requirements and their impact on religious mission. No contradictory evidence is presented.
Examine fact check →Colorado maintains that religious schools may participate in the program but must comply with the same nondiscrimination requirements as other schools.
Unverifiable
The excerpt from the Reason.com article explicitly mentions Colorado's policy regarding religious schools' participation in the program and the requirement to comply with nondiscrimination rules, matching the claim word for word.
Examine fact check →Approximately 2,000 preschools participate in Colorado's program, while only 34 Catholic preschools are involved in the dispute.
Unverifiable
The evidence from the Reason.com article explicitly mentions that about 2,000 preschools participate in Colorado's program and that only 34 Catholic preschools are part of the dispute, matching the claim exactly.
Examine fact check →The record does not identify any family headed by a same-sex couple that has sought admission for a child to one of these schools and been rejected.
Unverifiable
The claim is directly supported by the excerpt from the Reason.com article, which explicitly says the record contains no such identified cases.
Examine fact check →Colorado's attorney responded that equal access to publicly funded education requires more than the availability of alternative schools.
Unverifiable
The excerpt from the Reason.com article states: "Colorado's attorney responded that equal access to publicly funded education requires more than the availability of alternative schools." This matches the claim word for word, confirming its accuracy.
Examine fact check →The Catholic schools have a principled position and are not asking Colorado to endorse Catholic doctrine, only to permit them to maintain their religious mission.
Mostly supported
Both excerpts from the Reason.com article explicitly state that Catholic schools are not asking Colorado to endorse Catholic doctrine, but merely to allow them to maintain their religious mission. This directly supports the claim.
Examine fact check →The author wrote an article several years ago on Masterpiece Cakeshop, another Colorado religious freedom controversy.
Unverifiable
The claim is corroborated by the excerpt from the source, which explicitly mentions the author's prior article on the Masterpiece Cakeshop case.
Examine fact check →The author discusses these questions in a new episode of Legal Spirits.
Unverifiable
The evidence excerpt contains the exact phrasing confirming the author's discussion of the questions in a new Legal Spirits episode, matching the claim.
Examine fact check →