Fact check
“The opinion states that even if Congress enacted a law empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal Regulations, vacatur would likely still be inconsistent with the limited nature of the judicial power and the non-delegability of core legislative power to the judiciary.”
Reasoning
The provided evidence includes four excerpts from a Reason.com article citing Judge Kathryn Mizelle's opinion, which explicitly states that even if Congress enacted a law empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules and erase them from the CFR, such vacatur would likely still conflict with the limited nature of judicial power and the non‑delegability of core legislative power. This directly supports the claim.
On confidence: Multiple excerpts from the same primary source directly quote the opinion language, confirming the claim.
Important context
The excerpts are from a single article reporting on a district court opinion; no additional sources are presented, but the quoted language is clear and unambiguous.
Evidence
Supporting (8)
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
District Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional "Even if Congress were to enact a law clearly empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
is an excerpt from the opinion: Even if Congress were to enact a law clearly empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal Regulations, vacatur would…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
constitutional dimensions of vacatur as opposed to its statutory basis, and I have only gestured at them in the past, see K. Mizelle, To Vacate or Not to Vacate , at 19–20, I explain my doubts in full. First, I address why vacatur, if…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
still fails to cure those significant separation-of-powers issues. Finally, I conclude that, consistent with the Constitution, "set aside" in Section 706 is best read as a rule of decision when applied to agency rules. This is an issue…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
District Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional "Even if Congress were to enact a law clearly empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
is an excerpt from the opinion: Even if Congress were to enact a law clearly empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal Regulations, vacatur would…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
constitutional dimensions of vacatur as opposed to its statutory basis, and I have only gestured at them in the past, see K. Mizelle, To Vacate or Not to Vacate , at 19–20, I explain my doubts in full. First, I address why vacatur, if…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
still fails to cure those significant separation-of-powers issues. Finally, I conclude that, consistent with the Constitution, "set aside" in Section 706 is best read as a rule of decision when applied to agency rules. This is an issue…
Limitations
All evidence comes from one source; independent corroboration from the actual court opinion or other reporting is not provided. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.
- Last verified:
- Oct 1, 2026, 11:32 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
District Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) UnconstitutionalReason · Josh Blackman