Fact check
“Judge Kathryn Mizelle of the Middle District of Florida issued an opinion finding that the "set aside" remedy under the APA is (likely) unconstitutional.”
Reasoning
The supplied evidence consists of excerpts from a Reason.com article titled "District Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional" which quote Judge Mizelle's opinion and summarize her reasoning that the APA's set‑aside remedy likely violates constitutional limits on judicial power. These excerpts confirm that the judge issued such an opinion.
On confidence: The claim is directly supported by multiple excerpts from a Reason article reporting Judge Kathryn Mizelle's opinion that the "set aside" remedy under the APA is likely unconstitutional.
Important context
The evidence is a secondary news source summarizing the judge's opinion; the actual court opinion is not linked, but the article provides direct quotations attributed to Judge Mizelle.
Evidence
Supporting (5)
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
opinion will go up on appeal very soon.
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
District Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional "Even if Congress were to enact a law clearly empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
is an excerpt from the opinion: Even if Congress were to enact a law clearly empowering Article III courts to vacate agency rules or regulations and automatically cause their erasure from the Code of Federal Regulations, vacatur would…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
constitutional dimensions of vacatur as opposed to its statutory basis, and I have only gestured at them in the past, see K. Mizelle, To Vacate or Not to Vacate , at 19–20, I explain my doubts in full. First, I address why vacatur, if…
- Tier 1 — Primary sourceDistrict Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) Unconstitutional
still fails to cure those significant separation-of-powers issues. Finally, I conclude that, consistent with the Constitution, "set aside" in Section 706 is best read as a rule of decision when applied to agency rules. This is an issue…
Limitations
The verification relies on a single secondary source (Reason.com) rather than the primary court opinion. Access to the actual opinion would provide stronger confirmation. No independent origin corroborated this claim, so it cannot be verified and confidence cannot be high.
- Last verified:
- Oct 1, 2026, 4:31 AM CDT
- Pipeline:
- 2.1.0
- Claim type:
- Factual
Where this claim appeared
District Court Declares Vacatur (Likely) UnconstitutionalReason · Josh Blackman